wryan AT mindspring PISTE com (Will) writes:
> > Conning means intentional deceit. Do you seriously think none of the
> > religious people or leaders actually believe in their stuff, but just
> > lie that they do? I'd say such a conspiracy belief would be as
> > unsupported as any claims of gods or paranormal.
>
> Do you think that Stalin and his cornies were honest men who pursued
> the revolution out of the highest ideals?
First, you should not take a single sick dictator as an example of all
the people supporting the ideology. In any political movement there
always are such individuals who may get into power. Communism seems to
be especially susceptible to them, though.
Second, I don't know. You would have hard time proving that all or
even most religious people or communists or their leaders are
conners. People actually honestly believe in weird things and make
mistakes, probably I and you do too. Not everyone who has political
opinions different from yours are conners.
My point is, when there are conners, there are conned. When conners in
power die, conned get into power. (Well, at least they have the same
footing as any wannabe-conners.) Therefore, it is not reasonable to
say that followers of an obviously deceitful founder are conners.
> Do you think anyone who preaches that it would be all right if 1/2
> of the world should perish if it meant the other half would be
> Communist (as Lenin did), is a decent, honest idealist?
Has Lenin actually preached such thing or is that just your belief?
To my understanding, Marx's and Lenin's ideology was basicly about
freeing the proletariat from economical slavery. Working people's life
wasn't the same 100 years ago as it is now. They concluded that a
revolution was required to abolish the power structure.
Is a violent revolution a bad method? Most western democratic
countries have been born from revolutions that have been everything
but bloodless. Ah, "but they were for the right cause", sure! (You
might find more recent examples from South-America.)
> > Yes, communism is Utopia, a descendant of the Platonian Utopia. As
> > such, it is a genuine philosophical attempt to create a perfect system
> > of government. Being too utopistic and unthinking about human nature,
> > it has in practice resulted in horrible results. But it is not fair to
> > demonize the virtuous basic idea.
>
> Oh, boloney! You may not buy what Crazyalec has to say but he's in
> extremely good company. Solzhenitsyn, for one, argued that Communism
> is intrinsically evil, that it can lead to nothing but corruption and
> evil.
Intrinsically? Really? I'd like to hear his arguments.
I would see the necessary loss of various freedoms the only intrinsic
problem.
> In practical terms he was right, unless you know of a Communist
> state where honesty, virtue and freedom were maintained and honored.
I wouldn't say that freedom was maintained or honored, but honesty and
virtue are more difficult to estimate; I'm yet to see a country of
thoroughly honest and virtuous people, so it's hard to say.
> > That doesn't really prove much. Some people in any country can love
> > and some hate their political system, while actually living in the
> > same country.
>
> It means a great deal. He's seen it in practice, as did the citizens
> of the old Soviet satellite states and the Russians themselves.
> They've all rejected it, and there's hardly anyone today who can
> offer any defense for the brutality and repression suffered under
> Communist regimes.
Try the Chinese, North Korean, Cuban, etc. ;-)
You should also consider what the practice of capitalism was for the
workers living in the beginning of 20th century. For many, it was pure
slavery, living in inhumane conditions with barely enough money to
eat, with no possibility of education. If you had asked them about the
glory of capitalism, I'd guess you would have received an answer
similar to Crazyalec.
--
-- Marko Grönroos, magi<at>iki.fi (http://www.iki.fi/magi/)
|