[I tried to post this earlier, but it seems that the newsgroup
moderation settings weren't correct in our news server. News relay
software definitely should notice these problems and inform the
poster.]
Some creationist mathematicians and computer scientists seem to have
formulated their own "theory of information", which is supposed to
extend Shannon's theory of communication. This "Gitt theory of
information" is then used as an argument to "prove" that evolution is
impossible, because "information can not be created through a random
process", but that it always requires a mental source - God in the
case of genetic information.
Arguments based on information theories have recently become
increasingly common in both 'net debates and creationist literature.
After reading some articles on biosemiotics, I realized that Gitt's
theory is really just one semiotic theory of biological
information. Strangely, he or other creationists do not seem to make
any references to semiotic literature at least in their web articles
(I don't have their books though).
The main creationist sources seem to be:
1. The main features of Prof. Werner Gitt's theory are presented in
the article:
http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/magazines/tj/tj_v10n2p181.asp
The primary source seems to be his book "In the Beginning was
Information", see book advertisement at:
http://shop.gospelcomdirect.com/answersbookstoreintl/detail.asp?UID=10-3-086)
2. Another creationist scientist who has written about information is
Prof. William Dembski. His primary claims are presented in three books
"The Design Inference", "Mere Creation", and "Intelligent Design". His article
on genetic information is available on Web, at address:
http://www.arn.org/docs/dembski/wd_idtheory.htm
Then there is a discussion started by Richard Dawkins, who presented his
views on genetic information, in his article "The 'Information Challenge'":
http://www.onthenet.com.au/~stear/dawkinschallenge.htm
3. Creationist scientist Dr. Royal Truman wrote a commentary to
Dawkins' article, using Gitt's theory as the "scientific" basis of his
arguments. Truman's article is available at:
http://trueorigins.org/dawkinfo.htm
Some short comments to Truman's claims were written by an evolutionist:
http://www.world-of-dawkins.com/box/rebuttal_to_royal_truman.htm
4. A book "Evolution - Ein kritisches Lehrbuch" was published in 1998
by Prof. Siegfried Scherer and Dr. Reinhard Junker, with help from
about 15 other doctor-level scientists (mostly biochemists and
biologists). The book was recently translated to Finnish by a
creationist biochemist, Prof. Matti Leisola.
The book contains a section where Gitt's and Dembski's theories are
presented in brief and used as proofs for intelligent design.
(To my understanding, the academic credits of these particular
creationist scientists are valid. Their professional research is
apparently not about creationist views of evolution.)
Nevertheless, I think I have found many obvious flaws in Gitt's
theory, but as I'm not an expert with the topic, I can't be certain
about the actuality of the flaws. Biosemiotics and information theory
are, after all, heavy philosophical topics not meant for the
weak-minded (such as myself).
It seems to me that the most obvious and critical weakness in Gitt's
theory of information is the absolute requirement of a mental source
for all information. This seems ludicrous to me - most information
(encoded for example as light signals) received by human sense organs
(such as eyes) do not originate from a mental source, but from
inorganic nature.
Let me present a simple counterexample to Gitt's theory, which should,
in my opinion, crush it immediately. Bob wants to communicate the
weather to Alice. He uses a flashlight to send the signals. The
signals are coded with colored films so that a blue light means clear
sky, and gray light means cloudy. Alice knows and understands this
code, and can interpret the meaning of Bob's signals. Fine, they can
communicate. Now, Alice goes by the window and looks up at the
sky. The code is the same, and same amount of uncertainty about the
weather is removed from Alice as would have been if Bob had
communicated to her with the flashlight.
To my understanding, clouds are not usually considered a mental or
intelligent. That information - or "information-like thing" doesn't
fit in Gitt's definition of information, but it is still as useful as
information and actually looks like information. So I'd like to think
that "if it looks like information, it is information".
Will I hear the sound of Gitt's theory crumbling down?
So the general problem would be that if the definition of information
is made too strict in an invalid way, biological organisms will simply
not contain any information by that definition. In such a case, it
would be meaningless to talk about "increase or creation of
information", as information wouldn't even exist. Claus Emmeche's (see
reference below) view seems to be that the informational metaphor
should not be followed blindly in biology, as its usefulness as a
metaphor is not totally clear.
To me, this creationist appeal to the "scientific information theory"
seems like just one more creationist red herring or smokescreen
rhetoric; very similar to the false appeal for 2nd law of
thermodynamics in relation to biology/evolution.
Some sources on biosemiotics:
Claus Emmeche: http://www.nbi.dk/~emmeche/
Biosemiotics Homepage: http://www.ento.vt.edu/~sharov/biosem/
--
-- Marko Grönroos, magi AT iki PISTE fi (http://www.iki.fi/magi/)
-- Paradoxes are the source of truth and the end of wisdom
|