Charles Wagner <cewagner AT spec PISTE net> writes:
> Yes, and let the scientific community decide on the validity of your
> claim. Let's say that a few years back, someone claimed that dinosaurs
> had feathers and had pictures to prove it.
Could you please give us a demonstration of your skills in scientific
writing?
The problem with some articles may not be just the claim and the
observations, but also how they are presented. If someone writes an
article "Dinosaurs Had Feathers", simply shows some pictures, and then
concludes: "dinos had feathers", do you think that would be good style
of writing? Pictures do not tell everything. They would have to be
accompanied by good description about their context, lots of other
data, and good reasons WHY the picture really is about a dino.
So, even if the idea is ok, and the observations are relevant, a paper
may fail in giving the theoretical grounds for the observations and
conclusions.
Show us a paper that was rejected, with its rejection letter, and we
might give comments. Also remember that there doesn't really have to
be anything wrong in the article - it might just not be relevant to
the magazine, or not as interesting as other submitted
articles. Reviewers often give relative points, you see.
One conference had following requirements for the reviewer:
1. REVIEWER'S STATEMENT:
I have read this paper. I acknowledge that any new intellectual
content of this paper is confidential and will not disclose or use
it until such time as it is published by the submitting author(s)
otherwise becomes publicly known. This review is my own opinion;
I have written it; and I have not discussed my review of this
paper with any other peer reviewer for this conference.
I am not at the same institution as any of the authors.
I am not reviewing more than one paper for this conference by this
author.
I do not have an especially close relationship (or an antagonistic
relationship) with the author(s).
I am not re-reviewing this work (i.e., I have not, within the past
year, reviewed substantially the same work by the same author). I
feel that I am qualified to review this paper.
I've received following kinds of negative comments from reviewers:
3. SIGNIFICANCE OF THE PROBLEM:
... are a fundamental technology within ..., but the questions of
how they can be evolved has been well-worked, and this paper does
not extend prior knowledge significantly.
9. SUGGESTIONS TO AUTHOR FOR IMPROVING
Applying a variety of encoding methods to a common problem set, by
a third party, is of some value. But there is little insight
provided beyond the basic empirial results. So what?!
....etc...
These are of course vague, and I might not agree with them completely,
but I can't say that my self-judgement is necessarily better. Even if
they were wrong, I could still greatly improve the paper.
Thinking about that study now, over a year later, I know it was full
of crap and not even worth publishing. ;-)
--
-- Marko Grönroos, magi AT iki PISTE fi (http://www.iki.fi/magi/)
-- Paradoxes are the source of truth and the end of wisdom